• COMMUNITY
  • |
  • MY STUFF
  • |
  • DISCUSSIONS
  • |
  • CHAPTERS
  • |
  • GROUPS
  • |
  • PHOTOS
  • |
  • INVITE
  • |
  • EVENTS
  • |
  • FIND OTHERS
    Discussions

    Search Discussion
    Categories
    There are no topic categories.
    Most Recent Posts
    Linda  says:
    Beautiful Dan. I cried reading your post. I miss nature so much. Before my accident I used to love walking through the woods, hearing the leaves crush...

    Yea, it's me again - my son is the one who created the Paraflush Bowel Program. His next feat was....more than amazing!!! He made me a grandmother...

    My son became a paraplegic in 2010 from a horrible motorcycle crash.I remember his horror when he came out of the coma and began to process ...

    Jason  says:
    By keeping divorce on the table, mentally I feel one will find it nearly impossible to give it their all.  It's far easier to not consider ev...

    Candace  says:
    Thanks Dr. Dan, I so enjoy your posts and have gained great insight from them. I appreciate the reminder that what I focus on is where my energy will ...

    Showing items of 11

    Daniel Gottlieb, Ph.D., a practicing psychologist and family therapist, will be live in this section every Wednesday from 4-5 p.m. ET. Leave a question or comment anytime for him!  
    View All TopicsSubscribePost a Topic
    130 Posts
    Questions for Dr. Dan - Puzzle Pieces
    By ratherbflyin   


    Dr. Dan,


    I have a couple of questions for you, but please don't feel obligated to answer if you prefer to not do so. How long after your injury did you return to your practice and is your office in your home? Also, do you use voice recognition software for your writing and, if so, which product? These may seem to be random questions (they are), however, their answers provide information that is helpful as I am trying to put the puzzle pieces of my life together. This is an odd place to be at my age and I can use all of the input I am able to obtain to figure out where I'm going. I feel like kind of an outlier because of my age at injury (56) and being female. What is important to me now is entirely different than if I had been injured at an earlier age.


    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    Dr. Dan?s Response:


     


    be happy to answer your questions.  I got out of rehab in August 1980.  The following month I saw a patient or two a week in my house.  I think that was okay despite the fact that I felt so fragile physically and emotionally.  It was about six months later that I went back to my full-time job running a drug treatment clinic in Philadelphia.  But because my health was so unstable, I didn't want to jeopardize my disability insurance so I volunteered for about a year before I resumed full-time.


    I use Dragon dictate naturally speaking.  It's relatively inexpensive (about $200) and works really well.  It does have some conflicts with AOL and Microsoft outlook, but not anything major.


     


    Daniel Gottlieb Ph.D.


    DrDanGottlieb@aol.com


    www.DrDanGottlieb.com


    Blog: www.philly.com/askdan



     


     


    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    Comments from ratherbflyin:


     


    Thank you for answering my questions.  I am envious of your ability to resume your practice.  Mine has been stripped away and I'm struggling to figure out "what now". 


     


    I have been totally involved with going to doctor?s appointments, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and pool therapy since my accident in December of 2005.  Land PT has ended and pool therapy is winding down.  Next phase is a self-directed combination of home based and pool exercises to maintain functional gains. 


     


    All of this is to explain why I?m in a questioning mode.  I?m filing away answers to random questions or shared experiences as I attempt to extrapolate information that might help with construction of a new and very different life.  The answers from Dr. Dan are a few more pieces of the puzzle.      


     


    I just discovered that my new laptop computer has a Microsoft voice recognition and computer function command software program loaded in the hard drive that is one of the unadvertised accessibility features.  It is wireless and bluetooth compatible.  Computer information, as follows:


     


    Dell ? 17 in


    Studio 1737


    Intel Pentium Dual  CPU T3400 @ 2.16 GHz


    4 GB


    64 bit OS


    Windows Vista Home Premium



    Service Pack 1


     


    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    Are there others out there searching for answers to questions?   Ask Dr. Dan!  His answers and your comments might be just the information needed by a reader of this forum.


                                                                           

    ReplyRemoveEditUnsubscribeSubscribe
    Page  of  Total Items: 88

    firstprevnextlast


    Visit ratherbflyin's profile
    130 Posts
    ratherbflyin  says:

    FRIENDSHIP CHANGES?


    Another question for anyone out there.  Have you experienced a change of friends/friendships over time since your injury or illness?  I'm noticing changes here and am trying to pay attention to whether I'm isolating myself because I am feeling really depressed lately and don't care to be around others more than I have to (and who wants to be around someone who is down anyway?) or if they are just going through the normal changes over time.  It seems that my closest friends are moving on with their lives and I'm an outside observer. 


    BTW - Trish & Dr. Dan, hope your webchat tomorrow goes well and speaks to those out there who may feel so very alone with the challenges and rewards of being in a caregiving role.  

    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:
    "C"

    All of the above. Sure I lost friends after the accident. People who didn't know what to do more what to say or how to tolerate their own discomfort. And there were friends I stopped calling also for similar reasons. My buddies who I played softball with, even a couple we vacation with -- I just didn't know how to relate to them anymore.


    But when I became depressed and started to isolate, people couldn't find their way in. Fortunately, a lot of my friends are therapists and knew what was going on. My dear friend who was my mentor and teacher (and mother figure) finally said to me one day: "Dan, either you get in to treatment for your depression or I will drag you there!" Frankly, it was an act of love and felt like one.


    I've made many many new friends. People I love dearly and who love me. I don't know if that would have happened anyway or if it was accident related. But I'll tell you this, I feel very close to many people. And I also feel like an outside observer like I did when I was depressed. But this time, being an outside observer is really not sad at all.  Its much motr interesting because-of what I learned about people

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit ratherbflyin's profile
    130 Posts
    ratherbflyin  says:

    Questions for this week for Dr. Dan and others:


    As I've mentioned before, I have so many questions - new ones everyday - and am looking for answers from anyone with even partially similar circumstance.  I'm a 59 year old female quad with C5-7 injury and an additional brachial plexsus injury (seriously limits function of left hand) three and a half years post injury.  Anyone with answers you would share, please respond. 


    1)  How much caregiving do you receive daily, from whom, and for what issues?


    2)  Do you drive and, if so, alone and how often?


    3)  Do you travel alone or with a caregiver?


    4)  If you travel, how do you manage your bowel program while you are gone?  Do you have help with this or do your own program?


    5)  Do you have a regular routine daily and if you travel, how does your routine vary or how do you keep your routine the same regardless of where you are?


    6)  How much, how often, and what kind of exercise or stretching do you do? 


    7)  Do you manage your own medications - set-up, ordering, administration?


    8)  Do you have help with housekeeping, laundry, repairs, meal preparation, shopping, pet care, and, if so, how often?


    9)  Are decisions regarding your care, living situation, major purchases made by yourself, someone else, or with consultation and help from others?


    Thank you in advance for your responses!  

    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Trish-411's profile
    178 Posts
    Trish-411  says:

    My comments from a C3-C4 complete perspective and also a couple of new questions:


     


    1) How much caregiving do you receive daily, from whom, and for what issues?


    Approximately 50 hrs a week.  From agency LPNs or RNs.  For all issues. 


     


    2) Do you drive and, if so, alone and how often?  NO


     


    3) Do you travel alone or with a caregiver?  We have not traveled since the accident.  Mostly because I am too afraid to take care of my husband and kids away from home.  I envision too many things going wrong.  If we ever did, I would take a caregiver.


     


    4) If you travel, how do you manage your bowel program while you are gone?  Do you have help with this ordo your own program?N/A


     


    5) Do you have a regular routine daily and if you travel, how does your routine vary or how do you keep your routine the same regardless of where you are?  We have a very strict daily routine out of necessity.  That is what happens when you have hired caregivers scheduled for only certain hours.  If they are scheduled to come at a certain time for the bp then you do the bp then whether you want to or not. 


     


    6) How much, how often,and what kind of exercise or stretching do you do?  ROM daily and standing frame for about an hour at a time whenever we can fit it in.


     


    7) Do you manage your own medications - set-up,ordering, administration?  Nurses and I set them up and administer.  My husband orders his own stuff either through the local pharmacy or his mail order Rx plan.  I pick them up for him.


     


    8) Do you have help with housekeeping, laundry, repairs, meal preparation, shopping, pet care,and, if so, how often?  I am the ?hired? help for all of that with the exception that we have housekeeping every 2 weeks.


     


    9) Are decisions regarding your care, living situation, major purchases made by yourself, someone else, or with consultation and help from others?  Generally, we make these kinds of decision together.  My husband also suffered a TBI and has some short term memory loss and lacks motivation some of the time.  I kind of give him suggestions and put it on his computer to do list and often he will take care of stuff from that.


     


    More questions for Dr. Dan or anyone else.


     



    1. If your marriage ended after SCI, do you think it was because of the SCI or it might have happened anyway?

    2. Do you think it is appropriate to ever involve your children in your SCI care?  If so at what age and to what extent?
    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit ratherbflyin's profile
    130 Posts
    ratherbflyin  says:

    Thanks, Trish.  I'm treading water a bit trying to find out what is "normal" for others in my same situation.  Seems like a never ending process and while I have so much to be thankful for, the blessings don't really change the searching.  I doubt that there is any norm - that each individual comes to their own definition eventually. 


    Wish I could join the discussion tomorrow, but will be on the road again trying to have the plan "B" reversed or changed to plan "C" conversions for my SUV.  I spent four days last week out of town attempting to get the conversion I need to drive from my chair.  I have about worn this chair out using it as my primary means of transportation for more than 3 years.  As a result, my wheelchair's precise turning capability does not work well enough with the driver side automatic lockdown.


    Last week was a major challenge and most of the questions asked were as a result of some portion of the trip or the quiet thinking time during the drive there and back.  I traveled alone for the first time since my accident - a 3 1/2 hour drive into parts of this state that I had never visited.  I'm looking at the experience as a whole to see what I learned from the trip.  Tomorrow will only be a day trip to the same mobility shop and back home.  The weather will be good - kind of cool (60s) and sunny - a welcome break from the rain, storms, and tornadoes that will return on Wednesday.


    My daughter slept through a tornado that touched down less than a mile from our home while I was gone last week.  We also have more than 20 cases of swine flu in our tiny community that caused school and public event closings just before I left on last week's adventure.  Maybe the homefront will be quiet this time.    

    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:

    I love you guys but after reading all of your questions, in addition to quadriplegia I think my head just exploded!


    But I have a nurse (LPN) at home so she can help me clean up the exploded head and put it back together. She also does my medication, but I check it carefully with each dose. I am in a very small minority as far as caregiving is concerned. My accident took place in an automobile many years ago when there was something called no-fault insurance. They have legal responsibility to take care of all medical and rehabilitative expenses. So my car insurance pays for 24-hour nursing, Van modifications and wheelchairs. In my case, I need 24 hours nursing because I live alone. So I have a housekeeper comment once a week, but my nurse cleans up during the week and takes care of many meals. But given my age, my way of socializing is usually at restaurants so I am now for many meals. And yes I drive independently. Recently, I am not doing any more long-distance driving I have my nurse do that but I do drive in the area, to local lecturers and to the shore which is about an hour away.


    But what I really want to talk about is travel. My first trip was to my sister's apartment in Florida about five or six years after my accident. Took a nurse and after months of obsessive planning got on an airplane. My wheelchair went into baggage and (for once) was brought back to me in tact when I arrived at Florida. Also waiting for me was a rental van I had arranged. Frankly, the trip was difficult and stressful but I was thrilled that I did it and it opened the door for subsequent travel -- Grand Canyon, California, Hawaii twice, Israel twice and Alaska (no, I did not see Russia).


    And now -- the big one. I will announce more formally in a couple of weeks that I have been invited to receive the "fervent love of life award" in Taiwan. So after months of arrangements, I will be leaving on May 30 two fly to Taipei by way of Anchorage. I will be in the airplane approximately 20 hours going in 17 hours coming back. I'm pretty scared and pretty excited. Well, very much both. I will be taking a nurse and my hosts have arranged for me to have an adjoining room at the hotel. I don't think I'll have to worry about the bowel program because this trip has already scared the s**t out of me!


    I plan to start a new thread right before I leave so that I can post there from Taiwan.


    And Trish, whatever you are doing, it's probably not normal. So now you don't have to worry about that anymore and you can just say what you need to say.


    Dan


    and one other thing --


     


    And yes, spinal cord injury did contribute to the breakup of my marriage. But it was just a contributing factor. My wife had cancer when she was 24 years old and our daughters were only one and two years old. She lapsed into a deep depression and I became a workaholic. Then she developed symptoms of MS five years later and six months after that I had my accident.


    If a marriage is solid, and there is some history there, it can survive and even thrive. Sadly, marriages in which the man has the spinal cord injury are more likely to stay together that if it happens to a woman. Ladies, no need to comment on that it's pretty obvious you are the superior gender.

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit PRC_Bernadette's profile
    130 Posts

    Ratherbeflying~ I think we each set our own new "normal" and as we age our normal changes.  What I needed 19 years ago and what I need today are dramatically different.  It takes patience, a willingness to explore, investigate and be flexible in your needs. I have found that thinking outside of the box works best.


    Keep asking, it does eventually feel less overwhelming and all consuming.

    Posted:   
    "Every day I wake up is a good one"
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Trish-411's profile
    178 Posts
    Trish-411  says:

    I also wonder many times what is the norm or is this normal.  I have a couple of questions regarding this that I really want to pose to Dan, but I haven?t yet.  I think I am too afraid he will say ?Good God woman, that isn?t normal.?  So I?ll keep quiet for now.  I guess we all just want to be normal.

    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:

    For those of you who haven't read Tuesdays with Morrie, it's about a man who is dying of ALS and being interviewed weekly by his prot?g?, Mitch.  At one point in the interview Morrie blurts out anger and indignation: "my God, one day someone will have to wipe my ass!"


    My immediate reaction was "you'll get over it".  I remember having that same sense of outrage and indignation back in the beginning.  Now, it's just my life.  No big thing, really.  And that's not because I am particularly resilient, that's because that's what we do.  Those of us who live, adapt.  The ego gets in the way sometimes and becomes indignant and angry.  But after while if the ego can get quiet, we adapt.  We might not find joy, but we stop clenching our fists at the gods or the institutions or whatever.

    When I was commuting to work, I would leave a half-hour early so I could sit in front of my favorite lake and meditate.  Like most lakes, it was beautiful everything about it spoke of peace.  One day, someone threw a tire in the middle of the lake and half of it was sticking out. I was furious.  For weeks every time I stopped at the lake, I focused on the tire and became angry again.  And after while, my focus widened and I began to see the whole lake again.  One day, a year later, I noticed that the tire was now covered in moss.  I am not a botanist, but it looks like the lake was doing the same thing I was doing, making the tire part of the picture rather than fighting against it.
    Nature is so much smarter than we are.  I think it's about the ego thing.

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit ratherbflyin's profile
    130 Posts
    ratherbflyin  says:
    Congratulations on your award!  What a wonderful acknowledgement of your life's work.  Best wishes for your trip.  It sounds like you have your arrangements planned well.  At any rate, with your life experience, flexibility to meet challenges and unexpected events is a strong suit in favor of thorough enjoyment of the experience as it unfolds.  Happy travels! 
    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:
    Thanks so much, but I still hope to be making entries while I am in Taiwan.  Please check out the "on the Road" thread.
    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit sjean423's profile
    28 Posts
    sjean423  says:
    Trish-411:

    Do you think it is appropriate to ever involve your children in your SCI care?  If so at what age and to what extent?


    Trish, I just saw this.

    My kids were older than yours when I got hurt.  My daughters were 13 and 15, and my sons were 18 and 21.  The boys were in college in Boston, where I was in the hospital.  It made it nice in that they were able to visit almost everyday.  My youngest son spent his first "spring break" from college staying home to take care of his sisters, while my husband spent the time with me in the ICU.  My 15 y/o daughter spent a couple of nights with me in the hospital, alternating w/ her dad, when it was decided I shouldn';t be alone at night, due to what I now attribute to ICU "psychosis". Then for the next 12 weekends, the girls came up with their dad.  They spent time with me in PT and OT and learned a lot about what they could do.  Same with the boys when they stopped by in the late afternoons or early evenings.  My mom and I had figured a way to wash my hair in the sink in the hospital.  It was rather hysterical the first time I asked one of my son's to help, but aside from needing a dry shirt when I was done, it worked out fine.  So that is where I am coming from. 

    RE "SCI" type help .....

    Because they were so involved while I was in the hospital, it seemed obvious that for me they would help me at home.  The girls both did ROM with me for a long time, until I had it figured out for myself.  I don;t need dressing help, but they are the ones I call on when I have transferred too many times, and have just about transferred out of my pants.  My youngest daughter came up with the solution to one of  my shower transfer issues, and helped me perfect it.  I would dry off and put on a robe on the shower bench, as an attempt at modesty, but that was all it was.  We had a "lovely" Confused [*-)]Confused [8-)]mother-daughter bonding experience in the hc stall in a ladies room recently.  But this isn;t typical. 

    As a para, I really don;t need help with any medical issues, or B & B, on a daily basis, so I can;t address that.

    But everyone was taught how to help me transfer, which was still necessary in the early days.  Any of which may be called on to help if I end up in a swishy sofa, a strange car or more recently on an airplane seat.  We went camping recently, and my younger son and daughter transferred me in/out of bed.  (I wish rehab had taught us how to transfer, the 2 person lift like they do on the airplane ..... it is much easier that what we have attempted sometimes in the past with the slideboard.) They were really good about helping me turn early on, and settling me with pillows too.  (I am trying here to relate to things that your husband needs daily, that as a para I only needed help with in the beginning). 

    My kids were my primary chauffeurs in the early days too, and are still
    called on often.  (It is easier to go out w/ help ... especially if I
    have multiple stops.) Yours aren;t old enough yet, but keep that in
    mind ...... guess who can drive him to appointments, or go shopping
    with him in a few years!!

    I am trying to remember your kids ages .... preteens I think?  I am guessing they are already involved in fetching and carrying and such.  Turning pages if he is reading to him, and moving his piece in a board game.  I guess it is kind of a sliding scale as to what actually constitutes "sci" help, and what is just "normal" help.  The kids next door probably bring their dad a drink from the kitchen.  I doubt they put his shirt on for him, and I am sure they don;t change a catheter.    How much more involved they get in his care will probably have to be on a sliding scale too, as to what works for your family.  Kind of like getting him dressed every morning before school at age 8 is definately  too much, but doing so once in a while when they are 12 or so and everyone is in a rush is a different story?  Some help can be turned into good time too.  Helping you with ROM, leading into doing it themselves is a good time to talk, or read together.  I used to find that so with my daughter.  I would read aloud, or help her study during that time. 

    Personally, I am thinking too about the point that the spouse shouldn't be the primary caretaker (yea, I know, hard to follow this rule, but bear with me).  I would say that is true for kids too.  They are supposed to be his sons, not his nurses.  (You just have boys, right?  Apologies to your daughter if I am wrong.)  So I think the nitty gritty care (B&B, vent, bathing and such) should be avoided.  

    Another thing I would be careful of, is you don;t want to turn Dad into a "chore".   If it turns into something you have to nag them about, it is too much.  Otherwise, where the line is between "helping your dad" and "being his nurse" may have to come from your kids.     If either you, your husband or kids are feeling uncomfortable, or that it is effecting their relationship, it is too much.
    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:

    Dear Trish,


    what a wonderful response he received below it would be difficult to add any more to that. But I will share a few overall observations about SCI or any disability and the family.


    Any trauma to any individual is a trauma to a family. We all suffer and, by instinct, we all try to protect one another from their suffering. But the result is that everyone feels more alienated from each other. Children should neither be protected from the impact of SCI nor should they take on unreasonable responsibilities. Keep in mind, everyone in the system needs to have enough space and safety to express whatever feelings they want to.


    My daughter is where five and six years old when I had my accident. The summer after I got out of the hospital my wife was driving us all to a swimming pool when I had an accident and we all had to go home. My daughter said "daddy, I hate you for breaking your neck and ruining my life." I cried, but I didn't say anything other than I was sorry that this happened to all of us.


    My children are now in their 30s and they have gone through everything with me. That said, they have never had to change catheter or help me with a bowel routine. Thank goodness. But if they had to, they would and all of us would be embarrassed and angry and sad that we all had to endure that. And all of us would get over it in a very short time.


    What traumatizes our children is not the accident, but the way we deal with it. Sure, no matter what it adds a burden to their lives -- something we wish would never happen. But having a parent with a disability is not all bad news. These children tend to be more compassionate, responsible and more involved in the larger world around them.


    Hope that helps!

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit nanaboombala's profile
    89 Posts
    nanaboombala  says:
    Hi Dr. Dan.......after reading your response to Trish.......about how your accident affected your family.....I had to share with you......my experience. My children were 8-10 and 12 when I had my accident that left me a paraplegic. That was 26 years ago.....so I can see things from a distant perspective.......but a real on too. Of course, our whole family was involved......shaken......and certainly disrupted. Although my marriage didn't survive it......I have to say that the kids .......rose to the occasion.......and emerged finding strength and beauty within themselves......that I'm not sure......they otherwise would have. We went through all the struggles of daily living........but whether it was trying to figure out how to get my wheelchair up the school steps.......for our first parent teacher conference.........or.......having to prepare breakfast and make lunches alone.......cause mom was having those horrendous " leg pains "........the kids rose to the occasion.....time after time.......and what came out of all that confusion, pain,happiness and sometimes .....joy......was a family who.....to this day........knows that we can surmount......anything that comes before us........with the knowledge that we're strong enough......resilient enough to handle it........and that together........we can do almost.......aything.! As a direct result of my accident.......we all found a strength........a spiritual awareness........an inner something that made us better people........so much so.....that I feel somewhat indebted.......and can't really see my life.......any other way. Anyway......that's what happened in my family.......and I just wanted to share it. Thanks............peace and love..........Norma
    Posted:   
    Norma Carroll
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:

    Dear Norma,
    our stories are almost identical.  My children were small when I had my accident 30 years ago.  And I recall figuring out with my girls how to get in there elementary school for the first conference.  And now my grandson is trying to figure out how I can get on the beach with him!
    My daughters are in their mid-30s and both have scars from what they have lived with.  But they have lived with more than just quadriplegia and divorce, their mother had malignant melanoma when they were infants and she became severely depressed thereafter, and lots of other stuff.  So they have their scars and they are both a little weird in their own ways, but they are beautiful women in every sense.  In their own way, they're both devoted to making the world a better place.  Their level of compassion and sensitivity is extraordinary and I am so deeply honored to be their father.
    Norma, there is a new concept called: "posttraumatic growth".  And what we are learning from this emerging research is that although your story and mine are wonderful and life affirming, they are not unique.  How many parents of children born with disabilities have said that although they and their children struggle with the difficult issues, what has happened to them has made them better, more loving and compassionate people.


    Some think we should all keep in mind.  Posttraumatic growth.


    Nice meeting you Norma!


     

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:

    To follow up on my own post, I'd like to have a discussion about this concept of posttraumatic growth.  This is not the opposite of posttraumatic stress and most of us have experienced both.  So for all of our sakes, I invite you to take a clear minded view of the trauma you have left with and described the impact it's had on your life -- the good news and the bad news.


    Should open up an interesting discussion about what's happened to us and what it means


     

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit nanaboombala's profile
    89 Posts
    nanaboombala  says:
    Hi Hazeleyes......your word....resilience.....has such impact when we're talking about adjusting to accidents.....disease. Your mother sounds very special......through her strength.......you seem to be inspired to make this world a better place.......... so.what a heroic figure she cuts !The joy in small things..........your sensitive view of the world........all priceless gifts.......no ? You must be very proud of her.It proves part of what Dr. Dan is saying........about post traumatic growth ! There really is such an animal ! It lives ! Thanks for posting about your very special mother. Her ability to love life and be there for her children......in spite of her own special challenges.......inspires us all !................peace and love.......Norma
    Posted:   
    Norma Carroll
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit nanaboombala's profile
    89 Posts
    nanaboombala  says:
    Dr. Dan......first.....congrats on your very special "fervent love of life" award. Your trip to Taiwan should be quite an adventure ! I hope you are able to post.......and share the adventure with us.I actually laughed out loud when you said you wouldn't need to bother with your bowel program. It's comments like that that tell me why you won the award in the first place ! This study on post traumatic growth should be very interesting and informative. I'd love to hear other stories of trial and triumph.Nice meeting you also...Dr. Dan !.........peace and love......Norma
    Posted:   
    Norma Carroll
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit hazeleyes1's profile
    21 Posts
    hazeleyes1  says:
    Post traumatic growth ----resilience -that is what watching my mom battle her diagnosis for over 20 years has taught me.  She never lets it win over her love for life and being there for her children.  I have always noticed that I see things a little differently, as a child with a mom who has been slowly robbed of her mobility from a disease.  I also try to find joy in the small things.  Often the things that people overlook bring me an everyday joy.  I think it has caused me to have a more sensitive view of the world. 
    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Trish-411's profile
    178 Posts
    Trish-411  says:

    The way I can relate to this concept of post traumatic growth is through my first marriage.  I married when I was 25.  A year after our marriage, my husband was diagnosed with colon cancer.  After several surgeries and 2 different rounds of chemotherapy, he died 9 months after his diagnosis.  I sat in a hospital room for 48 straight hours and watched my husband die.  It wasn?t a peaceful experience because my gut told me we were both way too young to experience this.


     


    The only way I can put it is that I feel enhanced from the experience although I can?t say I am grateful that my husband died.  Of course not immediately, but over the months and years, I think his death allowed me to have greater compassion for others, certainly people with illnesses.  It also gave me an intense appreciation of marriage.  I realize that marriage is so precious and can easily be lost.  I think I also experienced a certain amount of emotional maturity I don?t think I would have gained any other way at such a young age.  My husband?s funeral was only the second funeral I had ever attended.  Being a widow while in my twenties had a way of shifting my priorities and values.  The little things most 20 somethings complain about didn?t matter at all to me.


     


    Today I feel blessed for what I learned from this experience with my first husband.  I think that experience has given me some of what I need today to survive my current husband?s SCI.  And maybe right now that is what I am wondering?will I find growth in this experience too?


     


    In the beginning of SCI, as a spouse you are just in survival mode.  There are so many things that have to be done and you just do them.  In the beginning you think things might change, you are hopeful that a cure is just around the corner but reality slowly sinks in that this is as good as it gets. After several years, the question comes, can I and am I willing to do this for the rest of my life and what growth is required for this new kind of marriage? 


     


    I think I come off here as a sniveling, hand-wringing, neurotic, caregiver wife.  But really I think I am just searching for a positive change that can come from these struggles.  This searching causes a lot of questions that I tend to post here.  I guess I have gone with the true intent of the forum On Healing.  If there was a forum On love, On joy, or On laughter I would have a lot to post there too.  That is the good news.


     


    The bad news is that both of these experiences have taught me that life is very fragile.  It doesn?t happen to someone else?it happens to me.  That thought has made me more cautious, a little over protective, and yes perhaps slightly neurotic.  With good there is always the bad.  Sometimes I just don?t know how much more growth I can stand.  

    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:

    What incredible thoughtful and deeply moving posts.  I feel honored to be part of this process and closer to those who have opened their hearts and taught us all more about what it means to be human.
    My story:
    when I was in seventh grade I learned about psychology and knew that's what I had to do.  I prayed and said I would do whatever it took to be a really good psychotherapist.  By seventh grade teacher who I idolized believed in me and introduced me to psychology.  Three months later, he molested me.  Lesson 1 -- child abuse
    Learning disabilities, mild depression and other stuff lead to school failure.  Flunked out of college my freshman year.  Lesson two -- learning disabilities and low self-esteem.


    Get married to a wonderful woman and have a baby two years later, another baby the next year and the next year she gets diagnosed with a life-threatening melanoma and a year of chemotherapy.  Lesson 3 -- being a caretaker


    three years later she develops multiple sclerosis.  Not sure what that lesson was!

    Six months after that I become a quadriplegic.  Several lessons about helplessness and vulnerability and letting go facing death and facing life and facing self-loathing.

    10 years later My wife leaves me.  Lessons on divorce


    same time my daughters go to college.  One falls apart and begins to self-destruct.  Lessons on help and helplessness with children (everyone is okay now)

    wife dies -- and you know that lesson.

    Multiple illness facing death -- the big lesson.
    That lesson gets reinforced now that I "celebrate" 30 years of quadriplegia as my body starts to show symptoms that no one can explain.  The big lesson.

    So my wish came true.  All of these lessons turned me into a pretty good psychotherapist.  A happy one anyway.

    I've learned about love and how accessible it really is.  And the more I love, the more easily I love.  Some people (many people) love me back, but that really doesn't matter either way I'm filled with love.
    And gratitude for all of the emotional and spiritual wealth I've enjoyed.

    I'll conclude with the dream I had several months ago.

    I was on a subway with several people and there was the angel of death.  Same picture we all have -- malnourished Darth Vader with a sickle.  All the other people were scared.  I wasn't.  At the next stop, they all ran off the subway.  I didn't.  He looked at me and pointed a finger and said: "January".  And then I woke up.

    I wonder if he was right.  And I wonder if maybe it's this January.  And if so, this summer might be my last.  And because of that it hass been the best summer I've ever had. And this posting feels open and rich and intimate. And this morning's bowl of cereal was especially good because I love summer fruit and I knew that would be ending soon one way or the other.


    .Today, I'm not afraid of dying.  I am afraid of not living.  And all of those lessons have taught me, if nothing else, love better and live consciously.
    Take care

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit ratherbflyin's profile
    130 Posts
    ratherbflyin  says:
    Blog Entry: http://tetratales.blogspot.com/

    Thursday, July 23, 2009

    Growth vs. Stress

    ---------------

    "The rung of a ladder was never meant to rest upon, but only to hold a man's foot long enough to enable him to put the other somewhat higher." - Thomas Henry Huxley

    ------------------------------



    Post Traumatic Growth (PTG) vs. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)



    The interesting question posed on the "On Healing" community forum by Dr. Dan Gottlieb (Christopher & Dana Reeve Foundation website) this week addresses the phenomenon of Post Traumatic Growth, in contrast to the more commonly addressed issue of PTSD. Dr. Dan asked forum participants to share their thoughts on the subject, both positive and negative. I have been pondering this question for several days and will attempt to share from my perspective.



    I remember vividly hearing my physicians and attorneys discussing my "catastrophic" injury. Catastrophic...hmmm, "what are they talking about?", I remember thinking. To me, this injury was just another challenge in what had been a long series of unfortunate events. Of course, to the people uttering these words, the visible nature of my spinal cord injury was the only part of my life experience in their awareness.



    Only I knew about the troubled thirty two year marriage left behind four years before my accident, the nearly successful suicide / homicide attempt by my husband the day after I asked for a divorce, my grandson's birth during the same time in which my then husband was in the hospital recovering from his injuries, the untimely death of this grandson at seven weeks of age from SIDS, my ex-husband's second suicide attempt, my daughter's spiraling down bipolar psychopathology after her son's death, two home break-ins, four moves, and three job changes.



    What have been the take-aways from literally losing everything, including nearly losing my life during this protracted eight year period of time? I will start with the positives because they are the first things that come to mind. It will take a little longer to consider the growth inhibitors / stressors.



    Faith. I have learned that some things are not controllable and now know that I will be cared for regardless of where life's circumstances place me. From the moment I realized that I was going to be crashed into, as I prayed out loud, I knew I would be taken care of. I remember hearing the words "it doesn't matter". My interpretation of that phrase was that whatever happened, it would be ok...and it was.



    Life is Precious. There are no guarantees in life. Life itself is tentative at best and can end at any given moment. How has that changed the way I live? I say I"I love you" much more frequently than before my accident. Every time my youngest daughter or I leave to go anywhere, we always say "I love you" and "be careful".



    Kindness of Others. My family and friends were treated with unbelievable care and kindness by total strangers. Every difficult situation requiring help, it was there.



    Patience. Waiting has become a way of life for me until recently when I resumed driving. Waiting for transportation, appointments, return telephone calls, obtaining new or needed equipment, learning new ways to do things, for my changed and often uncooperative body.



    Compassion. For others and myself along with a deeper understanding of how disabilities impact those who have them. Also for those who do not really understand the full impact of disability and are able to see life only through their own eyes.



    Forgiveness. I don't believe most people awaken with an intention to kill or injure another human beings. Bad things happen in every human life and forgiving those who may have caused an accident or injury frees up personal energy for healing. Remaining in the past or becoming bitter hurts the grudge holder rather than punishing others.



    Gratitude. Every day for the recovery I have been blessed with and for friends and family who love me and that I love.



    Expression of Grief and Sadness. Grief over losses and sadness that may follow as massive emotional and physical adjustments are made are a blessing in disguise - they open up space for necessary change. To quote a phrase from the 70s production "Free To Be, You and Me" - "It's ok to cry, crying gets the sad out of you."



    Love. Life is unpredictable and fragile. It is important to let others know what they mean to you at every opportunity.



    Resilience and Persistence. Giving up is not an option even when it appears exceedingly attractive. Turning the impossible into possible is only accomplished by bouncing back from bad things and working hard to overcome, accept, or adapt to continuous change.



    Mindfulness. Focusing on the present moment and appreciation of surroundings is a blessing that I frequently overlooked in my former, hurried, multitasking life. I am able to take the time hear and appreciate others' life stories more fully since my accident.



    Adaptability. I am amazed at how the body adapts to massive changes and continues to function and how creative people can be at finding new ways to accomplish tasks.



    Now, the negatives / stressors:



    Feeling overwhelmed

    Physical challenges and changes

    Disgust and procrastination of B&B care

    Role and identity losses

    Limitations

    Unpredictability of body

    Failed expectations

    Needing help

    Lost dreams



    I am certain that I have left out things, but this is a beginning...
    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit nanaboombala's profile
    89 Posts
    nanaboombala  says:
    Dr Dan......your very moving story was indeed.....open....and rich......and intimate. Thank you so much for that. You inspire truth.....courage....and most of all........loving......as the gift we all have at our fingertips......... you're a very, very special man...........peace and love......Norma
    Posted:   
    Norma Carroll
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit Dan Gottlieb's profile
    587 Posts
    Dan Gottlieb  says:

    Dear Randi's friend,


    so like you, I would love to find a person to love romantically.  And like you, I would like to find sex and caring and all that stuff. And as long as we are one thing, I would also like to be able to make love like I did before the accident!

    All worry is about the future.  So you have painted a picture of special people loving relationships and making love and now you fear that you will not have that picture.  A friend of mine had a traumatic childhood.  And like you, she also had a picture of what she thought she needed.  And she went through her life comparing her relationships, her children, her in-laws and everything to the picture she had in her head.  When I look at her life objectively, it looks pretty good to me.  Lots of people have loved her, she's had a good career and has wonderful children.  But she is so disappointed in her life because nothing ever fit that picture.  The problem wasn't her life, it was the picture.

    I live with longing also.  We all do.  It's not a call to action and it's not a need we cannot live without, it's simply a longing for something we don't have at this moment.  But there is another moment coming right around the corner and it could be Heaven, could be hell or, most likely, something in the middle.

    I wish your dreams would come true and I wish you were no longer afraid of you nightmare.  And most of all, I wish you happiness.

    Posted:   

    Dan

    Daniel Gottlieb PhD
    www.DrDanGottlieb.com
    Block signature
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit

    Visit randi's friend's profile
    4 Posts
    Dr. Dan: so many of us have had so much pain but we are learning to push on.    my biggest worry is never finding that special person to love.  You eventually lost your wife, how do you deal with missing a loving relationship like that.??  I really want to find love and sex and caring and understood the part where you said you are afraid of not living.     thnaks
    Posted:   
    ReplyDirect LinkRemoveEdit
    Page  of  Total Items: 88

    firstprevnextlast