• COMMUNITY
  • |
  • MY STUFF
  • |
  • DISCUSSIONS
  • |
  • CHAPTERS
  • |
  • GROUPS
  • |
  • PHOTOS
  • |
  • INVITE
  • |
  • EVENTS
  • |
  • FIND OTHERS
Blog Search
Blog Archives
Blog Latest Comments
Your chair reminds me of my white cane. I am visually impaired, though not legally blind, and just recently got my firs...
by Stefanie on Sunday, January 02, 2011
I am grateful for Laura, Robin, Sharon, Jean and all the other hard-headed women who taught me pride in my disability - ...
by lisbeth on Tuesday, November 30, 2010
I saw so sorry to hear of her passing. She was a very talented writer. My thoughts go out to her family.
by prc_Beth on Monday, November 29, 2010
I worked with Laura briefly in my policy-making work with Medicaid. Voices like hers are essential when trying to design...
by Lesley on Monday, November 29, 2010
I am so heartbroken! I was away all weekend where there was NO INTERNET or cell phone service. I literally just found th...
by WebProducerJul on Monday, November 29, 2010
Page  of  Total Items: 26

firstprevnextlast

Laura
Bookmark and Share
My Wheelchair, My Body, Myself
Posted by Laura
Tuesday, September 28, 2010
Comments (7)
by Laura Hershey

I don't know whether nondisabled people, or even the newly injured who are still getting accustomed to moving through the world in a wheelchair, can fully comprehend the connection between person and machine. When I'm in it, my wheelchair really does feel and function like a part of me. As such, I expect other people to give my wheelchair parts the same respect and/or affection that I want for my fleshier parts.

Here's what got me thinking about this: Last week I was getting on the city bus, heading home after a busy day. I backed onto the lift and the driver raised it. I started backing down the aisle toward the wheelchair space. Suddenly, from directly behind me, I heard a man's unnecessarily loud voice say, "I gotcha, baby sister!" Simultaneously I felt my wheelchair handlebars being gripped tightly, and pulled.

"No!" I shouted. Because I use a sip-and-puff tube to operate my wheelchair, my mouth was busy, so I had to keep my response short. "I got it!"

He kept pulling, and repeated, "I gotcha, baby sister!" He added, "I'm helping!"

By this time, the driver had converted the lift back into steps, and my attendant Krista had climbed aboard. She saw the guy yanking on my handlebars, and yelled, "Leave her chair alone!"

Perhaps he instinctively had more respect for someone standing, confronting him at eye level. He finally let me go, but continued to protest that he was just "helping."

Later, as I thought about this, I tried a thought experiment: What if a man came up behind an ambulatory woman and grabbed her tightly by both shoulders and started forcibly guiding her toward a seat? She would no doubt protest loudly, as I had done. If the man hesitated to release his grip, I imagine that another passenger might physically intervene. If a police officer could easily be summoned, the man might get a warning, or maybe even be arrested for assault.

For that's exactly what this felt like to me – an assault. It was a direct, physical affront to my person. This man wasn't just messing with some piece of equipment. He was interfering with my mobility, my power to position myself, to go where I want. My wheelchair is a part of my means of being in the world. In other words, it was part of me that he grabbed – my wheelchair, my body, myself.

Would anyone else recognize this? If I had tried to charge him with assault, would the legal system have supported me? Were other passengers aware of the depth of this violation? Or did they accept his statement that he was "helping" me?

It's hard to speculate about what other people are thinking, or about what might have happened if. But this uncomfortable encounter, with a man whose face I never even saw, did at least serve to remind me of the intense relationship I have with my wheelchair. When it's broken or unavailable to me, I feel limited in a way I never do when I'm in it. When it's working well, I move freely with its wheels and motors, and I interact with others from its comfortable seat.

I don't want other people to regard my wheelchair as public property, available to anyone who wants to use it for a foot rest, a topic of inappropriate inquiry, or a power trip.

But nor do I want them to view it as a barrier. That has also happened too many times. A few years ago, at the end of 10 days with a group of new friends and writers, our teacher was offering warm farewell hugs all around. She got to me, and hesitated. She wasn't sure what to do, how to navigate all the hardware in order to get close to me.

To her credit, she asked. I answered: "The left side works best. Come over here, and don't worry about leaning against the chair." It took some negotiating, but I got my hug.

Such qualms can be even more of a problem when pursuing romance. Potential partners who might have been attracted to me sometimes seemed put off by the physical presence of the wheelchair. Why? Maybe they saw it as an alien presence, a strange object that would always be in the way. Maybe they felt that it overwhelmed and diminished me, this big complicated contraption of electronics, wires, tubes, molded surfaces and customized supports. Maybe they had swallowed cultural stereotypes of wheelchairs as symbols of confinement, inability, immobility.

I know better. I know my wheelchair is part of me, and a part of which I am quite fond. It will change over the years – just like my other parts. It will even be replaced from time to time – just like all the cells in my body. There will be times when I fight it, times when I accept it. Sometimes we'll get along, and other times we'll be at odds.

Either way, the rest of the world better treat it right!


© 2010 Laura Hershey
 
Categories:  wheelchairs, attitudes
  • Visit Denese's profile
    Denese: This is a fabulous article! I too hate it when someone tries to push my manual wheelchair. I have had very similar experiences with Jodi who had someone try to "help" load the chair in the car. I pull my manual folded wheelchair into the back seat and frequently have to say no to "help" that is being forced upon me.
     

  • Visit Pioneer's profile
    Pioneer: This is a tricky subject.

    I understand exactly how you feel - but I am equally sure that the man did not mean to distress you.

    If your feelings are strong on this subject - which they obviously are - I would attach a sign to the back of the chair, making it clear that no-one should touch the handles. The wording would have to be your own.

    I am not an able-bodied person, and I have spent most of my adult life around wheelchairs and wheelchair users. I know that it is worthwhile taking time to explain in this situation. Otherwise you offend someone who is potentially an ally. He may have gone about it the wrong way, used flawed methodology, but his intentions were good.

    He simply had not been in your shoes, and therefore could not understand.
    I am left wondering how upset and hurt he felt at his "help" being refused.
    So while I understand your consternation and anxiety, I can only state, as you will know, that others are not nearly as aware as you are.
    The standing of someone with the disability is enhanced if allowance is made for the lack of experience of those more able..
    It is an ideal opportunity for education - don't let chances slip through your fingers!
     

  • Visit Jama's profile
    Jama: I've spent half my adult life in a chair now and I 'kinda' know how you feel. When I first got in a chair (I'm t-12 so I'm pretty ambulatory) I was absolutely insensed when people would grab my handles and try to push me around. I'd grab my wheels and scream at them to back the 'f' off.

    But now I've been in the rig for almost 15 years and have spent a lot of time in Asia where EVERYBODY tries to grab my chair. Sure, it's a bit insulting for them to assume they can get you around better than you can yourself, but it's also an act done out of kindness. So While I still grab my wheels, my response is no longer turse. It's, "Hey bro, I got it." That almost always does the trick. When people insist that they are there to help and you can just relax, I tell them that I'm working out and I need the burn the calories. That seems to always do the trick.

    I'm guessing in a sip and puff, if they insist you just tell them that you're 'practicing' and that might get them off your back. In the end it's all a public education process so taking the angst out of it will help everyone.
     

  • Visit Stefanie's profile
    Stefanie: Your chair reminds me of my white cane. I am visually impaired, though not legally blind, and just recently got my first white cane, thanks to the CNIB. I use my cane at night, in bad weather, or any time when I am going somewhere new, so I do not have to watch my feet to keep from tripping, and can instead keep an eye out for landmarks (since street signs are very hard for me to read). Without my cane, I do not go out by myself at night. With my cane I have much more freedom and independence. Life is much easier with it, though I do not use it all the time. People who make fun of me, or get mad at me, for having my cane, or people who try to physically guide me instead of letting me use my cane (because "using a cane makes you look weird"--I really do not understand this insistence on looks, or why they are so important) are not just messing with a piece of equipment. They are messing with me, and impeding my ability to go where I am trying to go. I do not like that.
     
View all 7 comments